But the fact that men are more virtuous than women all else equal doesn't tell us that they're more virtuous than women on average. If, in fact, men have greater temptation to do evil, then it seems we should expect them to simply do more evil.
You're right. That's why I say in the article I abandon the original argument and just focus on the hypothetical man and woman who both conduct acts of equal moral worth, and, I think when it comes to criminal justice, given neither the median man nor median women has a criminal convictions, men have greater virtue there in the real world.
But the fact that men are more virtuous than women all else equal doesn't tell us that they're more virtuous than women on average. If, in fact, men have greater temptation to do evil, then it seems we should expect them to simply do more evil.
You're right. That's why I say in the article I abandon the original argument and just focus on the hypothetical man and woman who both conduct acts of equal moral worth, and, I think when it comes to criminal justice, given neither the median man nor median women has a criminal convictions, men have greater virtue there in the real world.